# Humans are herbivores(?) Who would have thought!

- Link: https://richardmin.com/humans-are-herbivores/
- Published: 2018-07-08T16:15:10+09:00
- Author: Richard Min

[Internal]

Humans are herbivores. I didn’t know. 🙁 Now, this is my opinion, but I am going 
with this: Humans are herbivores. Hunter-and-gatherers, canines, not designed to
eat meat…  and herbivores. I didn’t have a clue. Nadda. Zip. I had no idea.

So, it looks like behavioral omnivores quite time now, but our biology make us herbivores.

Elephants (they’re the land-based biggest, strongest animals on the planet), gorillas,
rhinos, moose, etc. are land mammals. So, why did I think we were omnivores? I don’t
know. But somehow is fixed in my head.

And… my Ivy league, tech titans (oh yeah, the top of show) did so, too. I was one
of them. All of them still think humans that are omnivores. I had massive shift 
during my stroke (groundbreaking?), I still would have believe it.

I would definite put this in “soft sciences” (social science), especially this “(
carnivore), omnivores vs. herbivores” debate. Although I am “hard science” (natural
science) pseudo-person, I still think they are only “hard science” people – physics,
biology, chemistry, etc. They think that ‘on the basis of scientific investigations
to establish strictly measurable criteria’, and not “soft science” – archaeology,
anthropology, psychology, etc. where it is almost impossible to recreate ‘experiment
with exactitude’.

[> What Is the Difference Between Hard Science and Soft Science?](https://www.thoughtco.com/hard-vs-soft-science-3975989)/
[Dictionary: Hard Science](https://www.dictionary.com/browse/hard-science)/[Dictionary: Soft Science](https://www.dictionary.com/browse/soft-science)
<

It did not hurt I am a “whole food plant-based diet’…er. Doesn’t hurt. 😉

Here are two things that the omnivore’s group had to say:

 1. General and “Hunter-and-Gatherers”
 2. Canine teeth and forward face eyes.

That’s what I am going on now.

# Humans are herbivores!

Human are herbivores… with science!!

(Mic looks at Nathaniel Dominy, PhD, Biological anthropologist at Dartmouth… he 
is good.)

> How humans and non-human primates discern and acquire food resources, and how 
> the act of acquiring those food resources may have exerted a selective pressure
> on their anatomy in particular.
>  … But anatomically I would say we’re not adapted
> to meat at all. … A mix of plant foods with a large amounts of starch coming from
> tubers and seeds, that’s the fundamental component of the human diet.

 

Dr. Milton Mills

> “Our anatomy and physiology is a completely different than that of meat-eater.
> So, there’s is really nothing to supports of the idea that human being should 
> be consuming animal tissue.”

Human has very small, “canine” over time small and rounded and function like accessories
incisors.

> “They utterly useless for trying to rip and tear anything other than an envelope.
> They are useless for eating animal tissues.”

I picked one from 2010, just to show that it was possible (and he is the doctor 
and born in 1932. Ha!).

[William C. Roberts, MD](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_C._Roberts)

and young one, Sofia Pineda Ochoa, M.D. (and she is a doctor) and she goes over 
a lot.

# Human canines are meant for meat? Wrong.

### Teeth (dentition)

One of the most distinguishing features between mammals with different diets are
their teeth (Fig. 1). The dentition of a species has adapted to process a particular,
preferred diet.

Carnivores, for example, have very prominent, sharp **_canine teeth_** used to apprehend,
kill, and butcher their prey. Another set of characteristic carnivore teeth are 
the **_carnassials_**, which are the lower first molar and the upper fourth premolar.
These sharp, blade-like teeth shear against one another like a pair of scissors 
and are used to slice off chunks of flesh [1].

Carnivoran **_incisors_** are relatively small compared to the rest of the dentition,
with pointed, close-packed crowns that form a comb-like structure which the animals
use to groom their fur [1].

Omnivores, such as bears, generally have a similar dentition to that of carnivores,
with sharp, well-developed canines and small, pointed incisors (Fig. 1). However,
their carnassial teeth are not as well-developed as those of strict carnivores [
1]. Their teeth are not suited to process tough, fibrous plant foods [2], which 
is why they tend to either swallow their food in large, bite-sized chunks or crushed,
but not thoroughly ground and chewed.

An excellent example of dentition adaptation to diet within the same genus is that
of the polar bear (_Ursus maritimus_). The polar bear is thought to have evolved
between 700,000 and 150,000 years ago – which, in evolutionary terms, is rather 
recent – from coastal populations of the brown bear (_Ursus arctos_) [3]. However,
while the brown bear is omnivorous, only occasionally eating meat, the polar bear
is a strict carnivore, living on a diet of mainly seal flesh and blubber. As a result,
the polar bear has reduced molars and premolars compared to omnivorous bears, since
he does not require them to grind fibrous plant foods [4]. However, he also does
not have the sharp, well-developed carnassials of a true carnivore [4].

![](https://i0.wp.com/richardmin.com/website_541bd2bf/wp-content/uploads/2018/06/
herbivores-3-1024x915.jpg?resize=800%2C715&ssl=1)

_Fig. 1:  Upper and lower permanent dentitions of a typical carnivore (dog), omnivore(
bear), herbivore (deer), and a human [1]._

Here is a graph to show incisor territory dispute, for mates or central for social
communication.

![](https://i0.wp.com/richardmin.com/website_541bd2bf/wp-content/uploads/2018/07/
herbivores-1024x532.jpg?resize=800%2C416&ssl=1)

Territorial disputes

![](https://i0.wp.com/richardmin.com/website_541bd2bf/wp-content/uploads/2018/07/
hippos-1.jpg?resize=520%2C294&ssl=1)

Herbivores generally do not have prominent canine teeth. Exceptions are species 
that have large canines that they use for sexual display or agonistic behaviour.
Such is the case with gorillas or male musk deer (Fig. 2), for example.

Unlike carnivores, herbivores have broad, rather flat **_premolar and molar teeth_**,
which close in perfect occlusion and which they use to thoroughly grind their food
in a mortar-and-pestle fashion [5]. Plant matter requires extensive chewing in order
to break down tough cellulose cell walls.

![](https://i0.wp.com/richardmin.com/website_541bd2bf/wp-content/uploads/2018/06/
incisors-1024x475.jpg?resize=800%2C371&ssl=1)

_Fig. 3:  Schematic of the dentition of a dog and a human (redrawn after [6])._

**_What about humans?_**

Unlike carnivores, humans have spatulate incisors and reduced, rather blunt canines(
Fig. 3). The canines are similar in size to the adjacent incisors and premolars.
Our premolars and molars are broad and close in perfect occlusion – ideal for grinding
and chewing those fruits, vegetables, and grains.

### **All in all, our dentition has more characteristics in common with that of an herbivore**.

REFERENCES:

[1] Hillson, Simon. _Teeth_. Cambridge University Press, 2005.

[2] Feldhamer, George A. _Mammalogy: adaptation, diversity, ecology_. JHU Press,
2007.

[3] Slater, Graham J., et al. “Biomechanical consequences of rapid evolution in 
the polar bear lineage.” _PloS one_ 5.11 (2010): e13870.

[4] Sacco, Tyson, and Blaire Van Valkenburgh. “Ecomorphological indicators of feeding
behaviour in the bears (Carnivora: Ursidae).” _Journal of Zoology_ 263.1 (2004):
41–54.

[5] Hiiemae, Karen M. “Feeding in Mammals”. In: Schwenk, Kurt, ed. _Feeding: form,
function and evolution in tetrapod vertebrates_. Academic Press, 2000.

[6] Collins, A. _Animal Kingdom: Comparative Anatomy_. [www.slideshare.net/veterinaria_urp/animal-kingdom-comparative-anatomy](http://www.slideshare.net/veterinaria_urp/animal-kingdom-comparative-anatomy)

![chsiteveg.jpg](https://i0.wp.com/richardmin.com/website_541bd2bf/wp-content/uploads/
2018/07/chsiteveg.jpg?resize=715%2C342&ssl=1)

Humans are scavengers?  **In fact, we are much like a scavenger.** Hmm… scavenger?
Ah, maan, herbivores or scavenger. My head hurts!! (And scavenger? I’ll look into
to it.)

([Carnivore? Herbivore? Omnivore? — Scavenger.)](http://www.thegistoffit.com/the-dangers-of-giving-up-meat-part-two-carnivore-herbivore-omnivore-scavenger/)
<— Hmmm, interesting article.

Eh, but omnivore… no. I don’t like mysteries from the past (well, one’s can we can’t
solve), omnivores or herbivores. We can say that we are NOT carnivores. That much
is clear (I say, it’s clear!).  I say that we are behaviorally omnivores, but biology
we are herbivores.

Professor of Anthropologist of Dartmouth College (Ivy League), Nathaniel Dominy,
and evolution of the human diet:

 

Well, all this time, I thought we were omnivores. Who knew?

**_HERBIVORES!!!_**
 (or scavengers), not omnivores.

Daam, there goes my “Hunter-and-Gatherer” theory. (I’ll pick up “Hunter-and-gatherers”
in another post. 😉 )

 

 

---

Here is my others ones:

[Health… I never knew!](https://richardmin.com/website_541bd2bf/health/)

[Longevity](https://richardmin.com/website_541bd2bf/health/longevity/)

[Stroke and Aphasia (and my affect on it)](https://richardmin.com/website_541bd2bf/health/stroke-and-aphasia/)

### Share this:

 * [  Facebook ](https://richardmin.com/humans-are-herbivores/?share=facebook)
 * [  LinkedIn ](https://richardmin.com/humans-are-herbivores/?share=linkedin)
 * [  X ](https://richardmin.com/humans-are-herbivores/?share=twitter)
 * [  Pinterest ](https://richardmin.com/humans-are-herbivores/?share=pinterest)
 * [  Reddit ](https://richardmin.com/humans-are-herbivores/?share=reddit)
 * [  Email ](https://richardmin.com/humans-are-herbivores/?subject=%5BShared%20Post%5D%20Humans%20are%20herbivores%28%3F%29%20Who%20would%20have%20thought%21&body=https%3A%2F%2Frichardmin.com%2Fhumans-are-herbivores%2F&share=email)

### _Related_
