# Money Crypto vs. Tech Crypto

- Link: https://richardmin.com/money-crypto-vs-tech-crypto/
- Published: 2018-10-08T09:46:05+09:00
- Author: Richard Min

Money Crypto and Tech Crypto, what is the heck is the difference?

**Dictionary definition:**

“A digital currency in which encryption techniques are used to regulate the generation
of units of currency and verify the transfer of funds, operating independently of
a central bank. Decentralized cryptocurrencies such as bitcoin now provide an outlet
for personal wealth that is beyond restriction and confiscation”

**Level up: **

I know how crypto works, but I’m struggling beyond that.

Basically, **Money Crypto, **maintains that the point of cryptocurrency is to redefine
how money works and **Tech Crypto,** another belief system holds that the real point
is to redefine how the internet works.

“Ah ha! Wait… huh? I sort of get it…but something missing…”

Enter this man.

He’ll tell it to you straight. If not, oh well. I cannot give it to you any straighten
than that. 😅😜 So, read on!

---

# A Tale of Two Narratives: Money Crypto vs. Tech Crypto

One thing I’ve learned as an investor at [Village Global](http://www.villageglobal.vc/)
and avid participant in the crypto community via [Token Daily](http://www.tokendaily.co/):
say “crypto” at a cocktail party and you’re bound to start a lively debate.

Indeed: I’ve noticed that when people talk about _Why Crypto Matters_ and _where
The Big Opportunity is_, they often begin from different assumptions and starting
points. More importantly, there are often different endgames in mind, which leads
to confusion:

 * **Investors** are unclear what thesis they’re applying to the market.
 * **Startups **aren’t sure how to package their solution to satisfy everyone.
 * **Newcomers** struggle to follow along.
 * **Maximalists** spend endless energy trying to convince one group to think like
   the other, without fully appreciating where they differ (or align!) on first 
   principles.

Let me try to simplify by painting a (very broad) picture of the two main belief
systems in the space:

a) **Money Crypto: **Maintains that the point of cryptocurrency is to redefine how
money works by (re-)introducing Sound Money.

b) **Tech Crypto: **Another belief system holds that the real point is to redefine
how the internet works by introducing Web 3.0.

Others call these respective narratives “Bitcoin Maximalism” and “Ethereum Maximalism”,
but it’s broader and more expansive than that.

While there’s overlap between these belief systems, to be sure, they have different
aims, different approaches, and different philosophical underpinnings — which leads
to some of the confusion.

In this article, I will define each narrative, explain where they overlap and differ,
and what it means for the community at large.

## Money Crypto

Money Crypto believes that the goal of cryptocurrency is the introduction of Sound
Money.

Sound money is money that:
 1) Has either fixed supply or predictable inflation 
rate 2) Doesn’t appreciate quickly, and 3) Most importantly, can’t be controlled
by governments via inflation or confiscation.

### Why it’s important

With Sound Money, governments will be forced to behave responsibly because they 
are no longer able to borrow from tomorrow (via debt/inflation) to finance wars 
or fund short-term political objectives at the expense of long-term wealth.

Right now we have unsound money, which is a compounding problem. Having the ability
to print money — literally and figuratively — increases the power of any government,
and any government looks for anything that gives it more power.

This inflation, in effect, takes wealth away from people who produce it and gives
it to people who control money — without actually producing things valued by society,
and it does so _without citizens knowing._

In other words, governments can do whatever they want: confiscate, inflate, reward
nepotism, and finance trillion dollar wars  — all while hiding the costs via printing
money. At first, the citizens enjoy the newfound services — but they suffer the 
consequences later as they witness their wealth and purchasing power evaporate.

Money Crypto believes Bitcoin is an opportunity to return to our Sound Money roots
because Bitcoin is an un-inflatable, disinflationary, censorship-resistant, fixed-
supply asset that can’t be shut down by any government and operates without any 
trusted-third parties.

### Other core beliefs

Money Crypto believes that the web is a faulty analogy for studying the nature of
money and that we can instead learn more about the future of cryptocurrency from
studying economic history and how monies have emerged over time.

What can we learn exactly? That whenever people control money, they create more 
of it — insidiously diluting existing money holders in the process.

Money Crypto believes that we should treat cryptocurrencies as money — and not as
the next app store or the next software platform that captures all of the VC dollars.

Money Crypto is specifically “Bitcoin, not blockchain”. Nearly all Blockchain use
cases are not merely unnecessary — they also make the application slower and more
expensive.

Money Crypto believes that Ethereum is novel and interesting, but the value it creates(
let alone captures!) will be orders of magnitude smaller than the next money (Bitcoin).
All the apps / dApps being built on top of Ethereum will create some value — but
it won’t make ETH, the token, a better money. Yes, Ethereum has many more developers,
but Money Crypto believes 1 protocol developer is worth 10,000 app developers.

Money Crypto explicitly rejects the [Utility Hypothesis](https://multicoin.capital/2018/03/15/paths-to-tens-of-trillions/),
maintaining that digital money’s primary use case will be as [store of value first](https://twitter.com/fernandoulrich/status/1023941652468195330),
not medium of exchange.

Indeed: Satoshi used blockchain structure in an extremely specific and deliberate
sacrifice of a massive amount of speed & cost in order for us to achieve sovereign
level censorship resistance, trustlessness, and greater [social scalability](https://unenumerated.blogspot.com/2017/02/money-blockchains-and-social-scalability.html).

**To summarize: Money Crypto believes The Future of Crypto isn’t software — it’s
money.**

Crypto [isn’t equity](https://tokeneconomy.co/cryptocurrencies-are-money-not-equity-30ff8d0491bb).
It’s not a website. It’s not a company. And it’s not a social media network.

It’s money.

## Tech Crypto

**Tech Crypto, on the other hand, believes we should study the history of the internet
and its power structures — rather than the history of money — to help us understand
how cryptocurrencies will evolve and usher in the next epoch of the internet, Web
3.0.**

Tech crypto subscribes to the following narrative . . .

Although the internet started as a decentralized and open system, it quickly became
centralized and concentrated among 5 players: Google, Amazon, Apple, Facebook, and
Microsoft. They in turn addicted users, controlled their attention, monetized through
advertising, acquired those that compete, and shamelessly copied those who somehow
survived.

Far from fulfilling its original vision of decentralizing control, Web 2.0 has in
fact created power centers that are orders of magnitude larger than anything that
preceded the internet. Although the marginal cost of moving packets around on the
internet is 0 — and despite the amazing economic gains and consumer surplus that
Web 2.0 has produced — **the social costs have been significant: grotesque inequality,
end of privacy, fake news, monopolies, filter bubbles, a threat to democracy, and
more.**

Tech Crypto believes that the internet will only have increasingly more of a say
in how power and wealth are distributed. Fixing the incentives (via cryptonetworks)
is one of the most important things we can do, along with enabling consumers to 
own and control their own data.

Had the token model for network development existed during Web 2.0, things could
have played out differently.

 * Tokens provide a way not only to define a protocol, but to bootstrap the operating
   expenses required to host it as a service.
 * Tokens power the economic incentives to enable distributed computation — compute,
   storage, bandwidth — at scale in a decentralized way.

### An evolution of joint-stock companies

**Tech Crypto views tokens as the most salient innovation in human-coordination 
mechanisms since joint stock corporations centuries ago. **Before the joint stock
company, businesses had natural limitations. They were owned outright and no liquidity
to raise capital.

The advent of joint-stock corporations, and more recently publicly traded corporations
has produced incredible businesses that wouldn’t have been possible otherwise. We’ve
seen, however, the faults of those same systems: only employees are rewarded.

Value of a share of stock is a function of profits. And profits reflect a company’s
ability to monetize data — not the actual worth of the service. When a company reaches
a certain size their incentives become [misaligned with their users](https://medium.com/@cdixon/why-decentralization-matters-5e3f79f7638e)
and developers building on top of them.

### Incentivize all participants

Tokens also do something else which may enable the disruption of hitherto unbeatable
network-effect businesses: they — in theory — [incentivize orders of magnitude more people to contribute to the network](https://blog.coinbase.com/app-coins-and-the-dawn-of-the-decentralized-business-model-8b8c951e734f).**
This includes all stakeholders — users, developers, contractors, speculators — not
just employees.** Instead of accruing value by ownership (like equity), network 
participants accrue value by improving underlying protocol. This includes mining,
validating, building on top of, or using the service.

**How do you create the next Facebook? Give millions of people upside in its success**,
the theory goes, instead of just a few hundred.

And it’s not just tokens. Every aspect of blockchain infrastructure becomes a building
block for the next developer looking to build something on top of it. This leads
to compounding innovation since every application leads to more possible applications.
Just look at standards such as [ERC721](http://erc721.org/) or [0x](https://0xproject.com/)
turning into memes, leading to more companies starting, which then become building
blocks for creating more innovations on top of them.

In contrast, **Web 2.0 naturally led to silos and consolidation.** Tokens are the
fuel that both incentivizes protocol maintenance and development, as well as guarantees
enforcement of trust and openness.

### Other core beliefs

Tech Crypto says the blockchain will disintermediate all middlemen — not merely 
all of payments ($500B,) but banks, social networks, marketplace operators, etc.

Tech Crypto says that in order for money to be money it needs to be [used as money](https://multicoin.capital/2018/03/15/paths-to-tens-of-trillions/).

Tech Crypto is more bullish on Ethereum (but more open to many winners). They see
BTC as digital gold and Ethereum as the world’s computer, and are eager to build
millions of dApps on it.

Tech Crypto compares blockchain to the early web: people said the web wouldn’t scale
either, that it was an unnecessary toy.

Tech Crypto says that software tends to rewrite the rules of things it runs into—“
software is eating the world” — and crypto is no different.

Tech Crypto says don’t bet against developers.

## Which Narrative is Right?

Tech Crypto and Money Crypto in some ways couldn’t be more different — from their
beliefs to their vibes. Money Crypto are more economics-majors-turned-libertarian
anarchists. Tech Crypto are engineers and technologists trying to correct the wrongs
of Big Tech. To quote Murad Mahmudov: “Tech Crypto is more gentle, touchy-feely 
social justice-y positive vibe-y hippies. Money crypto is more carnivorous borderline
annoying intense uncompromising right-wing meat eaters.”

In reality, it’s too early to tell whether either or both of them are right – nor
are they mutually exclusive. It’s possible that both are right about the eventual
outcome but merely disagree about the order of operations. There are a lot of people
in Tech Crypto who are sympathetic to the Money Crypto narrative as a major component
of decentralization.

There are also factions that just wildly disagree. Some of Money Crypto believes
that Tech Crypto applications won’t accrue any value and that the near-religious
belief in tokens will dissipate when the ICO bubble pops. Some of Tech Crypto believes
that the money problems are overstated — to quote Chris Dixon in [Why Decentralization Matters](https://medium.com/@cdixon/why-decentralization-matters-5e3f79f7638e):

_“For example, it is sometimes said that the reason crypto network advocates favor
decentralization is to resist government censorship, or because of libertarian political
views. These are not the main reasons decentralization is important.”_

Ultimately, Money Crypto approaches this tech from a largely Austrian economics 
perspective, looking at at how monetary media have evolved over history and then
trying to replicate those same characteristics in digital form (Saifedean Ammous’
[The Bitcoin Standard](https://www.wiley.com/en-us/The+Bitcoin+Standard%3A+The+Decentralized+Alternative+to+Central+Banking-p-9781119473862)
is the manifesto here). Tech crypto, on the other hand, thinks that those historical
examples only go so far. Having money wrapped in software creates entirely new paradigms,
opens up the design space, and potentially even means that this time around, money
will take a much different path than it has historically.

#### _Money Crypto_ vs. _Tech Crypto_ Cheatsheet

  |  **Worldview** |  **_Money Crypto Belief_** |  **_Tech Crypto Belief_** |  
 |  Bitcoin/Ethereum |  Bitcoin Maximalist |  Ethereum Maximalist |  
 |  History to study |  Economics |  Web 2.0 |  
 |  Software |  . . . is trumped by money |  …is eating the world and creates new paradigms |  
 |  Disintermediation |  Banks |  All middlemen |

## Why they disagree

Some of these factions not only disagree, but also think of the other as detrimental.
Parts of Money Crypto believe that tech crypto is detrimental as it obfuscates the“
real value” of crypto — Sound Money — and that ICOs distract developers from working
on Bitcoin. There are parts of Tech Crypto that believe that the Money Crypto narrative—
and the often aggressive and hostile nature — is turning people away from using 
or building on top of cryptocurrencies.

It’s reminiscent of the great [Slate Star Codex post](http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/09/30/i-can-tolerate-anything-except-the-outgroup/)
about group infighting. Take Vegans and Paleo fans, for example. Rationally, observers
of both vegans and paleo diets should work on getting the general population to 
eat fewer cheeseburgers, because either diet is clearly an improvement over the 
status quo.

But, in practice, the human dynamics are such that they will not stop fighting with
each other precisely because their viewpoints are so similar.

Sound familiar?

**Similarly, I’d argue, any animosity between Money Crypto & Tech Crypto is better
directed towards their common enemies: central banks, corrupt governments, tech 
monopolies, etc. **I’d go further and say that both belief systems can benefit from
each other’s rise.

Without Money Crypto helping make crypto a good form of currency, Tech Crypto can’t
accomplish its goal of letting people get paid for hosting/mining/participating 
because they need their currencies to have value and be seen as compelling incentives.

And without Tech Crypto builders, Money Crypto people are climbing up a hill because
having a new ecosystem around digital currencies will give them credibility and 
value. (See the graph below – when crypto value gets higher, more people get wallets.
More people having wallets means more people can use dApps).

## Conclusion

To be sure, these concepts — Money Crypto & Tech Crypto — could be classified any
number of ways, but for the sake of clarity, we’ve excluded other, more granular
factions. What’s important to realize here is that not only can these narratives
both exist, we may find that they ultimately leverage and further the other’s chance
of success.

As entrepreneurs in the blockchain space, aligning around shared values should take
precedence over disagreeing over ideological differences that will resolve themselves
over time. We’re ultimately all just hypothesizing about the future and see blockchain
as a way to solve some of the world’s most pressing problems.

The complete article here: [Atrium.co by ](https://www.atrium.co/blog/money-tech-crypto)
[Erik Torenberg](https://www.atrium.co/blog/author/erikk/)

---

 

If that don’t clears thing up, you’ll get it on the next round.

(I mean… not here. 😜)

Ha.

### Share this:

 * [  Facebook ](https://richardmin.com/money-crypto-vs-tech-crypto/?share=facebook)
 * [  LinkedIn ](https://richardmin.com/money-crypto-vs-tech-crypto/?share=linkedin)
 * [  X ](https://richardmin.com/money-crypto-vs-tech-crypto/?share=twitter)
 * [  Pinterest ](https://richardmin.com/money-crypto-vs-tech-crypto/?share=pinterest)
 * [  Reddit ](https://richardmin.com/money-crypto-vs-tech-crypto/?share=reddit)
 * [  Email ](https://richardmin.com/money-crypto-vs-tech-crypto/?subject=%5BShared%20Post%5D%20Money%20Crypto%20vs.%20Tech%20Crypto&body=https%3A%2F%2Frichardmin.com%2Fmoney-crypto-vs-tech-crypto%2F&share=email)

### _Related_
